Refuse registration of the golden rule in the Constitution, without posing as supporters of fiscal laxity, is the tight play that engage the candidates for the primary socialist. In some links, their alternative proposals to the text of the government. François Hollande, Ségolène Royal and Martine Aubry oppose the rule of thumb budget that the government wants in the Constitution.
Manuel Valls: "supports the principle of a golden rule." Unlike the left, opposite to the "golden rule" supported by Nicolas Sarkozy, the deputy mayor of Evry takes a stand in favor of this measure but criticized the handling of the president who, with this project aims to set a trap over the Socialists to balance the budget.In an open letter to other socialist candidates in the primary, published on Sunday, Manuel Valls called for a binding commitment to progressive return to equilibrium enrolled in a five-year law and not in the Constitution as requested by the President. "It is useless to set constitutional objectives that can not be respected with regard to the degradation of our finances," said he. And he said that "the goal of a debt ceiling of 60% of GDP is 'constitutional' (Maastricht Treaty) and yet it will take a generation to fall within this ceiling …."."We need to propose a supplementary budget before any discussion on any golden rule." He concluded his open letter calling the Socialists to review their project "in the light of this crisis and its impact on our financial".
Read here: Open letter to Manuel Valls candicats socialist "Propose a true golden rule"
Segolene Royal: 7 rules for a "just social order." After the declaration of François Fillon has called the Socialists, on Saturday, to show "responsibility" on behalf of the "sense of national interest", and adopt the "golden rule", Royal replied on the offensive mode. In addition to the "golden rule", it proposes to add seven other rules, diamonds, silver, iron … to achieve a "just social order." It lists the rules that would halt all "unfair disorders" that currently prevail, she said.'The rule of diamond: the principle of fair taxation is also enshrined in the Constitution, the rule of money: that equal tax should be made between the CAC 40 companies and SMEs, the rule of iron that are prohibited stock options and over-compensation of traders. " "The rule of respect: that human values outweigh the financial values (…); the rule of common sense that a euro spent is a useful (…) euro, the growth rule: that is created a public bank financing of SMEs and industrial strategies that can generate jobs and increase wages. "Involving government policy for 4 years, the president of the Poitou-Charentes François Fillon asked if he could "say that if this rule controlling the public deficit was laid in 2007, you could hire the following expenses: tax shield, the ISF relief, exemption from overtime, creating tax loopholes and social? "
In response to the call for national unity, the Prime Minister: The 7 rules of Ségolène Royal against injustice
François Hollande, a planning law after the presidential 2012.Face to the call for national unity, the Prime Minister for the "golden rule", François Hollande offers, in an interview with JDD Sunday, a planning law after the presidential election. It highlights the management skills of its project."I trust that we all have the same goal of controlling public debt but we do not offer the same path to reach it. My approach is to make voting after the presidential law programming respect our European targets for reducing deficits. " He continues "The famous and controversial if rating agencies do not require a golden rule but concrete actions that may give lasting confidence."To overcome the crisis, he settled three objectives:" growth, without which there will be no return to balance accounts, under the budget, without which there will be no trust and tax reform, without which there will be no justice. "
For the position of François Hollande on the golden rule: his interview in the JDD
Martine Aubry: removal of 50 billion niche fiscales.Ce Sunday, the mayor of Lille hammered once again its opposition to the project of Nicolas Sarkozy. It calls on the government to adopt the 2012 budget measures to reduce deficits. Martine Aubry for the inscription of the golden rule in the Constitution is pure slogan. "For me, politics is not slogans, you know the slogan" work more to earn more. "Today is" changing the Constitution to do nothing ", she says .To reduce deficits, in addition to the renewed growth, it advocates the removal of much of the tax loopholes. "Today we have margins, these margins are these tax loopholes." And, "We want to remove 50 billion on 70 billion," she announces. Freed resources were intended "for half the decline in the deficit and half" to "priorities" that are "jobs, school safety."
Martine Aubry's arguments against the golden rule in his interview on BFM-TV
The PS trapped by the golden rule. The opposition socialists for the inclusion of the golden rule in the Constitution may bring into the hands of the government of Nicolas Sarkozy.The letter from the president to all parliamentarians, and the appeal of François Fillon, yet this weekend, so that members adopt a socialist attitude "responsible", the Socialist leaders are in a very difficult position. By refusing to vote the text of the government, MPs PS may move in the eyes of the public for proponents of fiscal laxity. The opposition is in a posture more and more complicated to take, while the market turmoil does not augur a crisis easy nor quick. The track is close to the PS, which is sticking to its position, homis Manuel Valls said that "not be hostile to the principle" to the regeneration of gold, while denouncing "communication operation" of the head of state.
To understand why the socialist position seems untenable, read: The Golden Rule, the trap to the left by Sarkozy